How would you rate episode 5 of
Firefly Wedding ? How would you rate episode 6 of
As I watched, I was struck by how closely these two episodes ofmatch the structure of manyhigh school romances, particularly the soapy, high-drama ones. If the characters were transplanted into modern-day, Satoko would be the new girl and Shinpei the handsome, untouchable popular boy. The crew of courtesans would be the mean girls who have formed a club devoted to the male love interest and are mad that Satoko has gotten too close to him. Aoi, the plain-faced courtesan who trains Satoko, is the dumpy girl whom the class picks on, only to be shocked when the heroine waltzes in and befriends her.
I was impressed at how Firefly Wedding made Aoi actually ugly, at least by the beauty standards of her day: freckled and obese, with small eyes and lank, greasy-looking bangs that her elaborate hairstyle can't conceal. She has a sweet nature, of course, and she and Satoko quickly bond in the face of bullying from Yukari and her goons. Of course, this isn't a high school romance where, if she survives, she'll graduate and escape. She's not a gentle high school girl, but a sex worker. Instead of graduating, she hopes the steady patron she calls her love will buy her out someday; without him, she has no escape.
The main story beats echo those of classic shojo melodramas as well: Satoko gets word that the madame wants her to get some firewood, only for her to be locked in the shed with Shinpei. The two have a heart-to-heart, and their true feelings come to light: Satoko never meant to marry him. She still means to go through with the arranged marriage once they return to the mainland. Naturally, Shinpei is furious, but before he can kill her as threatened, he sees that she's crying. Not out of fear like he first suspects, but because she feels terrible about breaking his heart.
Because, again, this isn't a high school romance, and while she has softened on him somewhat, Satoko is not in love with Shinpei; at least, not as far as she's aware. She's not a Reiwa or Heisei or even Showa teenage girl, allowed dreams or goals of her own, but a young lady of the Meiji, ruled by filial piety and the belief that her sole purpose in life is to marry. She's not allowed to fall in love; the idea of spending her life, whatever little may be left, with a person for the sake of companionship and comfort rather than advancing her family's status never occurred to her before meeting Aoi. Shinpei shifts gears; he won't kill Satoko, but her husband, and he'll keep killing them until there's nobody left for her to marry but him. Normally I'm not one to swoon over troublingly extreme declarations like that, but there was something terribly romantic about it.
Perhaps it was because, at her heart, Satoko is just as much of a freak as he is. After more subtle forms of harassment, the bullies finally ambush her in her room. With the two lesser goons holding her down, Satoko announces her intention to sew Yukari's vulva shut. Turns out, like any mean girl, all her power is granted to her by those she's convinced are below her, and Satoko manages to turn her followers around.
This is the part where, in a classic high school romance, Shinpei would sweep in and rescue Satoko. Satoko's defiance would only anger her aggressors further, and just before they were about to make good on their threats – perhaps with the followers getting nervous about their leader's determination to commit terrible bodily harm – here comes the handsome, troubled boyfriend. But Satoko is waaaaaaaay more emotionally volatile than, say, Kira from Mars, and she's ready to give as good as she gets. So when Shinpei comes crashing in, she's already kneeling over Yukari, ready to put needle to labia.
This episode brings some noticeable shifts to Shinpei and Satoko's relationship – not just the fact that she's finally being honest with him and he's decided to help her off the island anyway, but in the way they respond to situations. Satoko's survival instincts have made her more brutal, but we've known about the beast inside her since her very first scene. Shinpei, on the other hand, is growing less bloodthirsty. He spares Satoko when she admits she lied, and we know he's killed women for rejecting him before. Where once he may have killed or maimed Yukari for spearheading the plot to get Satoko raped by Nitobe, now he apologizes for leading her on. I have to wonder if his tendency to tell women what they want to hear stems from growing up in a pleasure resort, where relationships between men and women are built entirely on flattery and honeyed words. Whatever the reason, falling in love with Satoko has changed him.
Satoko will be okay, but someone has nearly faded into the background: Aoi. It was plainly obvious by the end of episode 5 that she was the one who locked them in the shed, thanks to her little smirk, but her motivation was not to hurt Satoko. Rather, she wanted revenge on Yukari, whom she believes is to blame for her patron no longer requesting her. She apologizes and runs off, and it doesn't take long for Shinpei and Satoko to realize that she intends to kill herself.
I haven't read much discussion personally, but this seems like the kind of scene that would rub some people the wrong way. Thus, I am here to defend it against its imagined critics. For one thing, Satoko is not exactly sensitive to Aoi's feelings in this scene. She scolds her for being so ready to give up, to give in to the men who insult her and then have sex with her for the novelty, and the girls determined to make her life hell. The two slap each other and wrestle, when many would argue that suicidal people should be treated more delicately. But Aoi isn't suicidal because of mental illness; she's suicidal because her life is awful and her only way out seems to have vanished. Nor is Satoko a particularly delicate or sensitive person capable of gently coaxing Aoi off the precipice.
Satoko's speech about being a person who chooses dreams over romance also seems contradictory, since her goal this whole time has been to get married. But to her, it is perfectly consistent: as far as she's concerned, getting married in order to pay her father back is the highest dream she could aspire to. Running off with Shinpei would be choosing romance, making the selfish choice her heart desires over what she believes is right. So much historical romance imposes modern-day mores on their characters, and Firefly Wedding refuses to. I'm completely enthralled by a determined, stubborn, fiery heroine who chooses her aspirations over love, and those aspirations are dictated by a patriarchal system that treats girls as little more than a bargaining asset. The contradictions are delectable.
Will that determination pay off? I don't think so; I'm still betting on my theory that her father was the one behind the kidnapping, or at least a knowing party to it. At the very least, though, someone will be getting a happy ending: some months later, Aoi's patron comes with an envelope full of cash to buy out her contract. She will get to live with her love after all.
Firefly Wedding is currently streaming on Crunchyroll.
<prev Episodes 1-2 Episode 3 Episode 4 Episodes 5-6