No one hits the ground running quite as hard and as often as Rumiko “The Queen” Takahashi. Say what you want about any of her other series, but it's hard to argue that over several decades of making manga, she's mastered the art of the introduction—of getting off to the right, and often very strong, foot. And thus, unsurprisingly, that was also the case for MAO. Unfortunately, the second half of the series couldn't quite match the strength of that introduction. And if you were hoping that new characters would be left to the anime's first cour , I have some bad news for you.
The second half is when we start seeing the overarching story really come into center stage. This part leans more into the supernatural, and has us frequently looking far further back than about a hundred measly years. This cour , after all, is more focused on Mao, Nanoka, and their allies, trying to learn the truth about what happened during that fateful night a thousand years ago—Did Mao actually kill Sana? Where did the Byoki come from? Who is, and isn't, an ally of the Byoki? Who's still walking the earth as a direct result of what happened that night, and who isn't?
These are exciting mysteries you can't help but sink your teeth into. There's so much potential here, it's absurd. Takahashi's masterful at drip-feeding just the right amount to her audience before her big reveals, and she's absolutely flexing that muscle at every turn in MAO. But for better or for worse, the mystery is a slow burn—so slow, in fact, that it ultimately doesn't amount to much by the end of the series. The ending feels more like a jumping-off point than a good, natural stopping point. Obviously, this comes as no surprise—the manga is still ongoing as of the time of writing, after all—but if you were hoping for a satisfying, standalone experience in this anime, I'm afraid you're better off looking elsewhere. Furthermore, because no questions see any meaningful closure, it's not exactly satisfying.
You may have already inferred this, but a slow-burn mystery that's doomed to go unsolved by the end doesn't exactly make for the most exciting watch. More often than not, questions are answered in ways that only create more questions, and you can only do that so many times before it goes from “Wow, I love that there are so many layers to this mystery,” to “Wow, this show is desperately swerving out of the way of giving us literally any substantial information. This is frustrating, and it makes me wonder whether Takahashi even knew where she was going with the story at this point. I feel like my time is being wasted.” This is a fine line MAO dances on throughout this entire cour , giving it a perpetual slowness that often taints even its best and most dramatic moments.
When this series isn't steeped in mystery, there's also, of course, a messy romance unfolding: Nanoka likes Mao, maybe Mao likes Nanoka, but he definitely likes Sana, but Sana liked someone else, but also Sana might still be alive—you see what I mean? Takahashi is queen of nothing if not the messy romance. And although we see our fair share of messiness here, we never get any big, dramatic payoff that makes it all so delicious. There's romantic tension in the air, sure, but the payoff is too small and too limited to feel worth caring about. It's much weaker as a romance, at least within this episode count, but once again, the potential is there.
Where this anime succeeds most, however, is vibes. More grim and horror-influenced than most of Takahashi's other works, the gray-tinted, increasingly supernatural world of MAO strikes a perfect balance between creepy, cool, calm, and chaos, with a more grisly edge. Nonetheless, you still get all of Takahashi's usual trademark charm, just in a much darker package. Things are eerie and blood-soaked enough for there to always be a lingering sense of discomfort, but it never gets too overwhelming, or laid on so thick that it starts to feel canned or synthetic. I think the fact that our protagonists and setting are likable-enough plays a big part in that, to be fair. But playing an even bigger role, without a doubt, are the show's more artistic aspects—music, visuals, and so on.
The overall production quality is also worth highlighting as one of the series' better aspects. The animation quality is good-but-not-great, has that quintessential Takahashi look, and stays consistent throughout. The music is atmospheric, and always helps get the mood just right—to say nothing of how cool it is that this cour treated us to a new opening theme by the group that used to be known as V6 , which feels like a full-circle moment for Inuyasha fans.
The voice acting isn't anything too exceptional—we've seen the legendary likes of Yūki Kaji (Mao) and Motoko Kumai (Uozumi) among others in better roles—but I suspect, given the quality of the cast and what the series has been like up to this point, that it's less to do with their acting ability, and more to do with just not having enough good opportunities to show off. As of this writing, the dub for the whole cour hasn't begun yet, but if things continue the way they've so far, it'll also make for a solid way to watch the series. In fact, I'd like to highlight how impressive that is in a series like MAO, which has as many long Japanese proper nouns as it does. Setting that aside, though, the voice acting itself doesn't stand out as especially memorable, but there are certainly some highlights. My particular compliments to Anjali Kunapaneni 's Nanoka. This is one of those series where preferring the sub or dub probably just boils down to personal preference.